When the Moon Was Ours

28220826by Anna-Marie McLemore
YA Contemporary / Magical Realism
5 of 5 stars

The trouble with reviewing a book of this quality is the fact that your own writing will be so inadequate you’re left using bland superlatives in an attempt to communicate the sublime experience you just had. It’s “incredible” “amazing” “beautiful” and really all anyone can take from that is “So you liked it a LOT.”

Yes, I liked this story a LOT.

This is magical realism at its most powerful. Miel fell out of a water tower when she was five and grows roses from her wrist. Sam is a bacha posh who paints moons and hangs them all over town. The two have been inseparable best friends until now, when they are seventeen and facing feelings that could change their relationship. Their growing attraction has to bend around Sam’s gradual realization that his identity as a boy goes deeper than the clothes he wears or the body he has. Miel has another reason for hesitance: the Bonner sisters (four girls the town views as witches) decide they want Miel’s roses and threaten to reveal all of her secrets—and steal Sam’s love away—if she doesn’t comply.

The small town is full of delicious, dangerous magic, and people that are all struggling to claim their identities despite the lies they tell themselves or the gossip other people whisper about them. Everything addressed in this story is handled sensitively and with an emotional resonance that will inspire you to see yourself and others in a nicer light.

That was the best I can do—add this to your list no matter what you normally read and let its magic unfold.

If you’d like to see more reviews or buy a copy for yourself, When the Moon Was Ours is available on Goodreads and on Barnes & Noble’s website here. Please consider supporting your local bookstore!


Similar reads:

  • Bone Gap by Laura Ruby – Finn is horrified when Roza goes missing, just like the rest of Bone Gap, Illinois. He alone wants to keep searching for her several months later, despite his disgrace. He was the only who saw the man that took Roza–but he can’t remember his face. This story is filled with magical realism and heartbreaking truths about people. See my review here.
  • Hour of the Bees by Lindsay Eagar – Another story featuring bees and magical realism, this one takes place in the Southwest. Carolina’s family is spending the summer at her grandfather’s ranch, prepping it for sale. Her grandfather is going to an assisted living home (against his will) and Carolina is caught in the middle of her family’s drama. Then her grandfather’s story about a village, a tree, and magic bees starts to seem less like fiction and more like family history. See my review here.
  • Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda by Becky Albertalli – Simon is only “out” with his mysterious email pen pal Blue. Both of them haven’t told each other their real names, but their growing relationship is threatened by another student who will expose their emails to the school unless Simon helps him land a girlfriend. See my review here.
  • Gabi, a Girl in Pieces by Isabel Quintero – Another story about learning not to spit on your roots–Gabi is Mexican-American and it seems like she is always becoming either too Mexican or too American for those around her. This book explores her senior year through her diary as she opens up to writing and dealing with the complex highs and lows of high school. See my review here.
  • Imaginary Girls by Nova Ren Suma – I love this magical realism story about a small town with a reservoir and two sisters–Ruby, who is everything, and Chloe, who looks up to her older sister. Ruby will do anything to keep her sister safe with her–even if it means bending the reality of their town and everyone in it. See my review here.

What’s new this month

The second part of fall release season is here! Take a look at these gems that are finally here:

2777927510/4 – This Adventure Ends – by Emma Mills

This is a case of cover love at first sight for me–so gorgeous! Sloane leaves Florida for New York, and falls in with twins Vera and Gabe. Fast friends, and maybe something more, Sloane becomes even more involved with them when their mother’s painting goes missing. I’m intrigued by the Goodreads’ hints of LGBTQ themes, and honestly I just want to see what happens and if this story lives up to the beautiful cover art. (Seriously, this aquamarine / seafoam color is my absolute favorite).

More here: Goodreads and Barnes & Noble


2822082610/4 – When the Moon Was Ours – by Anna-Marie McLemore

I am so excited for this! LGBT magical realism that sounds beautiful and incredible. Miel and Sam both have strange abilities and the two of them are inseparable. Miel has roses that grow from her wrist, and Sam hangs moons in the trees. They’re both threatened by witches who want Miel’s roses for themselves, to make anyone fall in love. There’s aspects of romance and dark magic here and I can’t wait to see how this unfolds!

More here: Goodreads and Barnes & Noble


2858834510/11 – The Midnight Star – by Marie Lu

The epic conclusion to Adelina’s story is finally here! I absolutely fell in love with this series last year. Adelina’s downward spiral into evil so well-done and so sympathetic. The writing is stellar, and I honestly have no idea if Lu is going to steer Adelina towards redemption or damnation. Now that she rules as the White Wolf, Adelina has lost everything she holds dear. What is her next move going to be? As the voices in her mind threaten to take control, Adelina must choose her legacy and her fate.

More here: Goodreads and Barnes & Noble


2330283810/11 – Goldenhand – by Garth Nix

This has been my one of my favorite fantasy worlds for almost twenty years! We follow Lirael again as she attempts to save Nick from Free Magic and learns there’s a message waiting for her with the Clayr and a woman from the north from her dead mother, Arielle. For the first time, we get an expanded map beyond the Clayr’s glacier! Although I suspect this will be much like the other stories in this realm, I can never resist the urge to return and see what’s new for the beloved characters (especially Sabriel and Mogget). I am so excited to see what lies in store for Lirael!

More here: Goodreads and Barnes & Noble


2548829910/11 – The Secret Horses of Briar Hill – by Megan Shepherd

Again, the cover grabbed me and the jacket summary held me! Winged horses, mirrors, and a little girl trying to protect them. The Horse Lord tells Emmaline he’s hiding one of his own winged horses, Foxfire, in her world to protect him from the Black Horse, which hunts by colorless moonlight. The magic is intriguing, and this story sounds like everything my junior high self would have loved so I am all in!

More here: Goodreads and Barnes & Noble


2741438910/25 – A Darkly Beating Heart – by Lindsay Smith

Time-travel between present-day and 19th century Japan! Reiko is an angry girl with unresolved issues. After a failed suicide attempt, she is sent to a small, historically preserved Japanese village. There, Reiko connects with the spirit of Miyu–the only person that might be more obsessed with revenge than Reiko herself. She will have to face Miyu’s demons and her own if she wants to live. I’m intrigued on multiple levels and I really hope this is good! Historical fiction seems to be the author’s strong suit so I hope to be swept away with this revenge tale.

More here: Goodreads and Barnes & Noble

%d bloggers like this: